A House Painting Dilemma

Daniel and I thought we had our house paint color picked out. But now we are second guessing it. Below is a before picture and theoretical after picture. You can see where I painted a little patch of green on the before picture. The second picture shows what the house would look like if we were to paint the whole thing that color (I didn't actually paint the whole house, I just altered the photo in photoshop). The trim will also be painted that creamy ivory color.

Here's the problem. I like the color. But I don't like it in our neighborhood. I've got two neighbors behind me with pale green houses that I look at all the time. Also, 3 houses up the street is a house with a similar green. I don't know. I think we will have to go back to the paint swatch book!